BankingOpinion
Banks Are Cutting Jobs for AI. They Still Can't Prove It's Making Them Money.
"It is hard to precisely distinguish how much of the benefit comes from AI."

The brief
- Banks are cutting jobs and slowing hiring as they reshape their workforces around AI, but evidence of AI contributing to revenue growth is limited.
- Barclays expects to cut about 5,000 jobs, primarily in operational roles, while attributing efficiency gains to broader technology investments rather than solely to AI.
- HSBC plans to cut management and specialist roles in its UK wealth business by up to 70% as it expands AI use for client services.
Banks are reshaping their workforces around AI, but most are still struggling to show what it adds to revenue. Job cuts and slower hiring are visible across the industry, while evidence that AI is growing the top line remains limited, CNBC reported on November 16, 2026.
The brief
- Banks are cutting jobs and slowing hiring as they reshape their workforces around AI, but evidence of AI contributing to revenue growth is limited.
- Barclays expects to cut about 5,000 jobs, primarily in operational roles, while attributing efficiency gains to broader technology investments rather than solely to AI.
- HSBC plans to cut management and specialist roles in its UK wealth business by up to 70% as it expands AI use for client services.
"It is hard to precisely distinguish how much of the benefit comes from AI," Santander CFO José García Cantera told CNBC.
The Workforce Changes
Barclays expects to have cut about 5,000 jobs by the end of 2026, around 5% of its workforce, with most cuts in operational and functional roles.
CEO C.S. Venkatakrishnan credited most of the efficiency gains to broader technology investment, including modernising platforms and simplifying systems.
He said AI "may have a more important role to play in the future," but described it as "the icing on the cake – it's not the cake." Barclays expects about £600 million in structural cost actions this year.
KBW analyst Andrew Stimpson told CNBC that bank layoffs were "partly driven by AI, but not entirely attributable to AI," and concentrated in back-office and support functions.
At HSBC, about half of management and specialist roles in its UK wealth business are expected to be cut, and financial adviser roles could fall by up to around 70%, the Financial Times reported in October.
The cuts come as HSBC expands its use of AI to serve wealthy clients, including tools that give relationship managers market insights and personalised investment strategies.
An HSBC UK spokeswoman said the bank is "continuing to evolve to deliver more digitally-enabled products and journeys."
At JPMorgan Chase, AI has reduced the headcount needed for certain work in some departments by roughly 30% to 40%, according to remarks by CEO Jamie Dimon reported in July. "Most of those workers were offered other jobs elsewhere," Dimon said.
In May, he said the bank would likely hire fewer people for some traditional banking roles and more AI specialists and data scientists.
Where the Value Shows Up
Some banks have started putting numbers on AI. Santander said its AI work generated €194 million in business value this year, combining higher revenue, lower costs and lower loan-loss provisions, without a breakdown by category.
García Cantera told CNBC that AI mainly reduces low-value processes, affecting both revenue and costs.
The industry data points the same way. Banks surveyed by D.A. Davidson expect AI to reduce expenses by an average of 4.5% to 5%, compared with a 2.5% to 3% increase in revenue, S&P Global Market Intelligence reported.
nCino's AI in Banking Benchmark found that 91% of banks have an AI strategy and 71% track clear KPIs. But the most common measure is employee productivity and workflow automation, at 45%, while only 21% measure whether AI contributes to increased revenue.
A separate Deloitte study of more than 570 financial services leaders found that 18% generate revenue from AI, while 75% expect to.
The Revenue Test
Analysts say the clearest benefits so far are in service and productivity. Sophia Whitbread of Ninety One told CNBC the strongest evidence is in customer service, engagement and productivity, rather than directly quantifiable revenue.
She called wealth management "the most important testing ground for revenue growth."
Costs are also rising on the other side of the ledger. McKinsey's Global Banking Annual Review, released this month, said spending on AI tokens, compute and operations could reach as much as 20% of banks' labor costs.
McKinsey's Vik Sohoni told Reuters that banks are narrowing their AI deployments to the use cases with the clearest returns.
Analysts cited by CNBC said AI's impact on revenue remains harder to demonstrate than its effect on costs and productivity.
Join the discussion
0 answers
People who run these systems answer here. Your verified role is shown, never your employer unless you choose.
Sign in with LinkedIn to answer
Read next
Chaos Predictions — every Monday
Where enterprise AI is heading next, read from the week’s deployments across banking, pharma, manufacturing and retail.
Free. One email every Monday. Unsubscribe in one click.












